Portals #1 by Nic Carcieri and friends.
20 page black and white minicomic with color covers.
Why describe this minicomic to you myself when I can just quote the author's note that came with the book? "Portals is a self-published bi-montly anthology book containing four of my orignal stories." Well, sort of. My problem with this book, and with a lot of minicomics in this style, is that it does not really contain stories or even bits long enough to be considered episodes of stories. What you get is more like a collection of trailers for stories. This happens a lot in minicomics and especially in books like this that are created by a writer using multiple artists. I know how the trailer comic happens as I've done them myself. When you are a writer that loves comics and wants to make them you might be able to get several artists to knock out four to eight pages for you but it's hard to get an artist to knock out a full twenty-two page comic without putting up some money. And even if they would do it for firee, it's hard to impose on a friend like that. So, you ask around, meet folks at conventions and online and the next thing you know you've got a bunch of comics trailers and you make a book out of them. It's not a bad thing. I would just prefer one solid story or at least something that feels like a solid episode of a story to the trailer comic collection.
The four pieces in this book range from three to seven pages each. It is hard to review Nic Carcieri's writing in this book because the stories never get going but it feels like the writing was learned from movie trailers and comic books. Each story is from a different genre so I respect the ambition of the book but what I see here feels more like a person doing an impersonation of those genres and less like someone telling a story that really means something.
This is a good looking book but there just is not enough of any one piece to sink your teeth into. And it's not that I don't like anthology books. My suggestion would be to slow down the publication shceduling goals and focus on having longer episodes. Then it would feel a lot more like a winning issue of Heavy Metal and less like a collection of trailers.
Your best pal ever,
Shannon Smith
Tags: nic carcieri, reviews
Comment
About
Partner Site
Latest Activity
click HERE to read
I can't imagine keeping up with a daily diary strip, much less one that anyone would be interested in reading. Not that I don't find them interesting myself, just that I don't think I'd be up to the challenge. It was tough enough when I used to keep…
Looks like fun!
Nice cover, Rob!
Oh, I will SO be going to both! I wouldn't miss either one.
Come on you guys can make it to both. They're less then an hour apart on the road. I really like the direction Jesse is heading Gem City. I think we both need to be boarded up in our cabins for the winter to put our shows together and that's why the…
Rick, Unfortunately this will only be digital. The cost of a color 100 page anthology as a POD or small run book would be expensive. I already produce an printed anthology in the form of Oh,Comics! every year. The latest issue is available at http:/…
Bristol International Comic and Small Press Expo at Bristol, UK
May 21, 2010 at 6pm to May 23, 2010 at 5pm
Bristol's very own comic convention, covering comics from mainstream and small-press publishers, with a whole host of guests, contributors and exhibitors!
Tickets on sale now!
'Gin Palace' is now on sale! It looks great! I've put it on sale at my website shop if anyone wants to buy it with paypal. It's 40 pages with colour covers, priced £2.50 or about 4 dollars (free postage in the UK but I'd have to charge for elsewhere…
Aren't I just?! I really should wear it less often though: at this rate I'll need a new one before Summer. I'm such a groupie.
I was just reading the review of the latest Lewis Trondheim collection over at The Daily Crosshatch, when I was struck by what is probably by now a very well-rehearsed question: why do we do daily comic strips? What function do they serve, for the c…
lol
Fashionable! I still need to get myself one of those t-shirts...
© 2010 Created by Rick Bradford on Ning. Create a Ning Network!
You need to be a member of Poopsheet Foundation to add comments!
Join Poopsheet Foundation